In this guide, you’ll find all the necessary steps to create the perfect database design for a learning management system.
A database design for a learning management system must be able to gather and relate information about courses, course categories, students, course enrollments, teachers, classes, attendance, exams, and scores. Once you have this information in a database, you can use it to query relevant data and obtain all kinds of analytics, such as attendance rates per course and per teacher, pass rates, and score averages.
Don’t know exactly what data modeling is about? No worries! Read up on data modeling basics in 10 minutes and you will be right on track.
Before You Start Data Modeling
Before you start drawing the model, you’ll need to be familiar with the requirements and the scope of the project.
The Requirements List
A requirements list for your learning management system database model might look like the one detailed below. This list must have the approval of the project stakeholders, so you can work safely. You’re less likely to hear that phrase that causes us software developers terror: “This is not what I asked for”. Remember that, among the many things that a database designer does, an important one is to correctly interpret what users and stakeholders really need.
The requirements list sets out the conditions, constraints, and criteria on which you will base your design. For a learning management system, these might include:
- Course information includes a course code (unique identifier), a course name or title, start/end dates, course category, course abstract, and bibliography. The course category must belong to a list of predetermined categories.
- Students’ registrations must contain their names and email addresses. Other data, such as date of birth and telephone number, can optionally be registered.
- Teachers’ registration must contain their names and email addresses. Optionally, their telephone numbers can also be included.
- A teacher can teach more than one course, and more than one teacher can teach one course.
- Each student can enroll in one or more courses. When a student enrolls in a course, the date of enrollment is registered.
- A student’s enrollment in a course can be canceled. In that case, the reason for cancellation is registered.
- A course consists of a certain number of classes, which are numbered sequentially. Each class is held on a specific date and at a specific time. Each class must have a descriptive title of the subject it covers.
- Students’ attendance in class needs to be registered for each person. The time of arrival and time of departure should be saved in the attendance records.
- A course can have an arbitrary number of tests or exams, numbered sequentially. For each exam, the database should store the date and time it is taken and the topics it covers.
- The database should keep a record of each time a student takes a test, storing the score obtained.
Setting the Scope
Requirements engineering also gives us a scope definition. That is the boundary that separates what the software will do from what it will not do.
It is convenient to state explicitly the functionalities that could be considered part of the system but that for some reason will be left out of the scope. For example:
- No course pricing information or course billing will be recorded.
- The approval conditions for each course will not be stored in the model. The justification for this decision is that the course approval mechanisms usually present many variants. Trying to systematize these mechanisms would add too much complexity to both the application and the data model.
Clearly establishing the limits of the scope of a project helps us avoid misunderstandings and false expectations about the development to be carried out.
Generating the Logical Diagram
The first step in designing your learning management system database model is to identify the entities for which you need to store information; these will end up becoming database tables. The input for this task should be a requirements list. By carefully reading this list, you will surely identify a set of entities like these:
- Course Category
You can now create a conceptual diagram for your learning management system that would contain all of these entities. But in order not to get into too much detail of the model creation process, let’s skip some steps and go directly to drawing the logical data model. This requires making a series of design decisions, supported by the requirements list.
You might want to learn more about the conceptual, logical, and physical data models before we continue. You can also check these example entity-relationship diagrams for ideas on other types of data models. You can use a tool like Vertabelo to do your data modeling tasks more efficiently.
After your logical data model is complete and validated, you will be able to create a physical model. But first, please read 8 things to consider when creating a physical data model to take advantage of the experience of someone that has done it quite a few times.
To identify the courses, students, teachers, and other entities of the schema, you may adopt the criterion of giving each element an alphanumeric identifier of 10 characters. These identifiers will be unique for each entity, so you can use them in each table as primary keys. Remember that you should always define a primary key for each table. If this is the first time you’ve seen the term “primary key”, maybe you should first read about what is a primary key before going any further.
The entities to be created can have other unique identifiers. In the case of students, for example, the email address should be unique for each student. This restriction can be enforced by assigning indexes that don’t allow duplicates. But it is not a good practice to use a field that could be modified (such as an email address) as a primary key. That’s why it’s advisable to use an abstract identifier as the primary key; this way, users can freely modify the rest of the data.
A good way to document your design decisions is to include text notes in your data models.
Courses and Categories
For each course, your database must be able to record the code, name, beginning/end date, an abstract of its contents, and the recommended bibliography. It should also indicate whether a course is open (signaling that it is open for enrollment) or closed (to prevent new students from enrolling). In addition, the course must be able to be associated with a certain category of courses.
Below, we’ll add all the information related to courses to our database schema: course schedules, the list of enrolled students, the list of teachers, attendance records, exams... but let’s take it one step at a time.
For now, you can diagram a basic outline for your
Categories tables by drawing the two tables and setting a foreign key relationship between them.
A basic outline for the Courses and Categories tables.
An important question to decide when designing a learning management system data model is whether the same course can be taught again or only once in a lifetime.
Most commonly, the same course is taught repeatedly in successive years. But this poses a problem. When a course is repeated in a new academic year, how can you record the new start and end dates without losing the data from the previous academic year? The same will happen with the rest of the course information, since all the information may change from one academic year to the next.
One solution to the above problem is to normalize the schema. In the
Courses table, you can leave only the data that does not necessarily change from one academic year to the next: code, description, course category, abstract, and bibliography.
Then you can create a table of academic cycles. (It’s better to use “cycles” instead of “years”, in case an academic cycle does not coincide with a calendar year). This table will contain the description of the academic cycles along with their start dates, end dates, holiday breaks, etc.
A third table will relate
Cycles so we can identify the courses taught in each academic year. In this way, course data that varies from one year to another – such as start and end dates, faculty members, student enrollments, etc. – will be associated with this table instead of being associated with the “mother”
With these modifications, your diagram would look like this:
An improved version of the schema, after applying some normalization.
Students and Enrollment
Up to this point, your schema is capable of storing course data and associating it with academic cycles. Now you should add the capability of registering the data of the students attending a given course.
To do this, you’ll first add a
Students table. This table will have the following attributes: the student’s ID number (an alphanumeric code), name, email address, and optionally their birth date and phone number. The alphanumeric code will identify each student univocally, so you can use it as the primary key.
The Students table definition.
Then you need to think about how you’ll store enrollment data. You know (following the requirements definition) that each student can be enrolled in one, none, or many courses. And you know that each course can have any number of students enrolled. It is very clear, then, that there is a many-to-many relationship between
Let us now consider which of the two courses tables (
CoursesPerCycle) should be related to the
Students table. When a student enrolls in a course, they do so for a given academic cycle. In other words, enrollment in a course is not a permanent thing; it is only valid for the duration of one cycle. For this reason, you should link the
Students table to the
CoursesPerCycle table instead of linking it to the main Courses table.
To link students with their courses, you’ll need the
Enrollments table. This will contain the course ID, the cycle ID, and the student ID, which will form a composite primary key: no student can take the same course more than once per cycle. (If the student takes the course a second time, that will be in a different cycle.) You’ll also store the date of enrollment and a Boolean value indicating if the student canceled their enrollment in this course. The optional
CancellationReason column will record the reason for the cancellation.
The Enrollments table links the Students table with the CoursesPerCycle table.
Teachers table will be designed in a similar way to the
Students table. It will have an alphanumeric ID that you can define as the primary key. In addition, it will have fields to store the teacher’s name and their email address, as well as an optional field for a phone number.
Each course can be taught by one or more teachers, and each teacher can teach one or more courses. Therefore, there must be a many-to-many relationship between courses and teachers, which will be materialized in a table called
TeachersPerCourse. It will contain links to the
This part of the schema should look something like the following:
The TeachersPerCourse table links the Teachers table with the CoursesPerCycle table.
Classes, Attendance, Tests, and Scores
To fulfill the complete list of requirements, you only need to add entities for student attendance and test results.
To register students’ attendance in a course, you need a
Classes table; a row is stored for each class taught in the course. A class belongs to a course and an academic cycle, so you’ll need a one-to-many relationship between
Each class must have a date, start time, end time, and a teacher. (To avoid overcomplicating the schema, you can assume that each class is taught by a single teacher.) In addition, you can give each class a sequential number and a title or description of the subject matter:
The Classes table is a subordinate of CoursesByCycle. Therefore, its primary key is composed of that of its master table with the addition of a correlative number (ClassNo).
Each class may be attended by many students, and each student may attend many classes. Therefore, you’ll need a many-to-many relationship between
This relationship will have two attributes of its own:
TimeLeave. These register students’ time spent in the classes (although you may make this data optional, in case you don’t need so much detail about the students):
The Attendance table links Students with Classes, adding two attributes of its own: TimeArrive and TimeLeave.
The only thing left to do is create a
Tests table and link it to the
Courses table in a similar way as you did with
Tests will also be associated with the
CoursesPerCycle table. You can give each test a correlative number, a date, a time, and a free text field to contain the test topics.
Then you can create another table,
TestScores, where the test results can be stored. This table links
Students. This part of the schema should look like this:
The tests and scores sub-schema.
With these last additions, you have covered all the requirements. Now you can present the complete database design:
The complete database model for a learning management system.
Possible Changes to the Learning Management Data Model
This diagram allows you to generate a database that meets the requirements stated at the beginning of this article. By making some changes, it could be adapted to a different set of requirements. For example, for an online course management system, the dates and times of classes and exams would be irrelevant. Each student could freely choose when to take a class or an exam. It could also be that the concept of an academic cycle does not apply because courses are always current and are not tied to an academic year.
All these changes are relatively easy (and inexpensive) to make as long as they are made early in the software development life cycle. For this purpose, it is convenient to work as much as possible with the logical diagram, converting it into a physical diagram only when it is time to implement it on a given database engine. A design tool such as Vertabelo is an ideal ally to make the most of the resources related to data modeling and database design.